Apple AirTags: Are You Betting on the Wrong Tool?

Over the past three years of developing T-Trak, Apple AirTags have been on my radar, but I’ve largely dismissed them as a robust vehicle tracking solution. At the time, my decision to set them aside wasn’t based on concrete evidence—just an assumption that they weren’t suited for the role. However, over the last couple of weeks, AirTags have started grabbing my attention, and I’ve gained some firsthand insight into their capabilities and limitations.

Recently, I rode in a vehicle equipped with an AirTag. Shortly after the ride, I noticed a notification on my iPhone indicating that an AirTag had been detected near me. As someone who works in the vehicle tracking space, this notification immediately raised concerns. Apple’s anti-stalking feature essentially alerts individuals to the presence of an AirTag traveling with them, which means a car thief could easily discover it and take steps to disable or remove it or remove himself from the vehicle. This revelation made me question their viability as a stealthy theft recovery option.

Another observation I’ve made relates to the accuracy of AirTag location data. The map generated by AirTags often lacks precision. In one instance, it displayed a location in Lake Michigan—a place I certainly hadn’t been. The tracking trail also appeared inconsistent, with abrupt jumps that didn’t reflect a smooth or reliable path. These two issues, combined with the notification feature, suggest that AirTags may fall short of being a dependable primary solution for vehicle theft recovery.

I will be the first to admit that "EVERY" vehicle tracking system on the market has its strengths and weaknesses, and I would strongly recommend adopting a layered approach for theft prevention and recovery if you are going to deploy apple AirTags to protect your vehicle. Below, I’ve outlined the publicly discussed pros and cons of Apple AirTags, along with a few parting thoughts to consider.

Apple AirTags - Pros and Cons:

Apple AirTags have gained popularity for tracking personal items like bags, keys, or wallets. However, their use for recovering stolen vehicles is a hot topic, raising questions about their effectiveness, limitations, and ethical implications. Before you incorporate them into a strategy for vehicle theft recovery, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons.

Pros of Using Apple AirTags for Vehicle Theft Recovery

1. Affordable Tracking Solution

Apple AirTags are relatively inexpensive ($29 per unit or lower in multi-packs), making them an affordable alternative to more sophisticated GPS tracker systems. For those on a budget, AirTags provide basic tracking functionality at a fraction of the cost.

2. Easy Integration with Apple's Ecosystem

AirTags work seamlessly within Apple’s ecosystem using the "Find My" app. If your vehicle is lost or stolen, the app lets you quickly locate the AirTag, as long as it's within range of other Apple devices on the network.

3. Crowdsourced Location — Ultra-Wide Network

AirTags leverage Apple's vast "Find My" network, consisting of hundreds of millions of devices worldwide. When the AirTag is separated from its owner, nearby Apple devices can anonymously detect it and relay its location to you via the app, making it an effective tool for finding stolen vehicles even outside Bluetooth range.

4. Compact and Discreet

AirTags are small and easy to hide within a vehicle. Placement options include inside glove compartments, under seats, or within crevices in the trunk, potentially making it harder for thieves to detect and remove.

5. No Monthly Subscription Fees

Unlike traditional GPS trackers, the AirTag doesn’t require monthly subscription fees. This makes it a cost-effective solution for vehicle owners who don't want recurring costs.

Cons of Using Apple AirTags for Vehicle Theft Recovery

1. Limited Capabilities

AirTags rely primarily on Bluetooth and Apple’s "Find My" network rather than dedicated GPS or cellular connectivity. If your stolen vehicle is in a secluded area with few nearby Apple devices, the AirTag may fail to provide accurate location data.

2. Short Battery Life

While the replaceable battery in AirTags can last about a year, this isn’t ideal for long-term tracking. Forgetting to replace the battery could leave your vehicle unprotected at a critical time.

3. Vulnerable to Detection and Removal

If a thief finds the AirTag, they can remove it or disable it. AirTags emit periodic beeping sounds to alert nearby individuals of their presence, making it easier for criminals to locate and discard the device.

4. Ethical and Legal Concerns

AirTags can raise privacy issues. Apple designed the device with safeguards to prevent misuse, such as anti-stalking alerts. However, these same features can frustrate recovery efforts—for instance, thieves may receive notifications that a hidden AirTag is tracking them, tipping them off before recovery teams can act.

5. Not Designed for Vehicle Tracking

AirTags are optimized for tracking personal items, not vehicles. They lack features like real-time tracking, geofencing, and speed monitoring—all essential tools for dedicated vehicle tracking systems.

6. Dependence on Apple Ecosystem

For Android users or those without Apple devices, AirTags are virtually useless. Their utility depends entirely on access to Apple’s "Find My" network, so they may be unsuitable for non-Apple device users.

Conclusion: Is It an Optimal Solution?

While Apple AirTags can play a role in recovering a stolen vehicle, they are far from an optimal solution. Their affordability, ease of use, and reliance on Apple’s extensive network make them attractive, but the lack of real-time GPS tracking, susceptibility to detection, and dependency on nearby Apple devices limit their effectiveness.

For optimal vehicle theft recovery, it’s best to invest in dedicated GPS tracking systems equipped with cellular connectivity, real-time monitoring, and anti-tamper features. However, AirTags might serve as a supplemental tool if paired with other security measures in a layered approach, especially for users already operating within Apple’s ecosystem.

Suggested Advice from VKIIOT

If you’re considering AirTags as part of your vehicle theft recovery plan, think of them as an additional layer of protection rather than your primary solution. Combine AirTags with other security measures like VKIIOT's professional vehicle notification and GPS tracking solution, along with steering wheel locks to reduce theft and or maximize your chances of vehicle recovery.

Learn more  NOW!!!!

We are more than a vehicle tracker a whole lot more.